Category Archives: Against the War-Support Our Troops

Rumsfeld On Meet The Press: How The Casualties Are Worth Winning This War

This is from the November 2, 2003 program of Meet the Press.
Rumsfeld: The Casualties Are Worth Winning This War (Small – 3 Mb)
Tim Russert:
“So far, we have lost 377 Americans in Iraq. 2,130 have been wounded or injured.
How would you explain to the American people this morning that it is worth that price for the war in Iraq.”
Donald Rumsfeld:
“Tim, the uh, battle we’re engaged in. The global war on terrorism. Is an important one. It is a different one than we’ve been in previously. Although terrorism’s not new. But the nature of terrorism is that its purpose is to terrorize. Its purpose is to alter people’s behavior. And to the extent free people end up behaving in a way that is different from the way free people behave, they’ve lost. And therefore, the only thing to do is do what the President has announced he’s doing, and that is to take the battle, the war on terrorism to the terrorists. Where they are. And that’s what we’re doing. We can win this war. We will win this war. And the President has every intention of staying after the terrorists and the countries that harbor terrorists until we have won this war.”

Injured American Soldiers Claim They Have “Never Been So Treated Like Dirt”

Just to clarify again — These stories are not about our soldiers not getting proper medical treatment on the front lines. They are about Shrub War Veterans not getting propers medical treatment upon returning home.
But wait! It’s worse than that. Upon re-reading the article, I see that many of these soldiers had existing health problems that should have prevented them from being deployed in the first place. I also see that many of them were forced to reside in substandard housing, and received injuries from incidents like the roof falling in on their own barracks, rather than in active combat.
I hope the citizens of our armed forces can remember this experience long enough to vote the Shrub out next year.

By Mark Benjamin for UPI.

“I joined to serve my country,” said Cpl. Waymond Boyd, 34. He served in Iraq with the National Guard’s 1175 Transportation Company. He has been in medical hold since the end of July.
“It doesn’t make any sense to go over there and risk your life and come back to this,” Boyd said. “It ain’t fair and it ain’t right. I used to be patriotic.” He has served the military for 15 years.
Boyd’s knee and wrist injuries were severe enough that he was evacuated to Germany at the end of July and then sent to Fort Knox. His medical records show doctor appointments around four weeks apart. He said it took him almost two months to get a cast for his wrist, which is so weak he can’t lift 5 pounds or play with his two children. He is taking painkilling drugs and walks with a cane with some difficulty.
Many soldiers at Fort Knox said their injuries and illnesses occurred in Iraq. Some said the rigors of war exacerbated health problems that probably should have prevented them from going in the first place.
Boyd’s X-rays appear to show the damage to his wrist but also bone spurs in his feet that are noted in his medical record before being deployed, but the records say “no health problems noted” before he left…
Sgt. Buena Montgomery has breathing problems since serving in Operation Iraqi Freedom. She said she has been able to get to doctors but worries about many others who have not.
“The Army did not prepare for the proper medical care for the soldiers that they knew were going to come back from this war,” Montgomery said. “Now the Army needs to step up to the plate and fix this problem.”
In nearly two dozen interviews conducted over three days, soldiers also described substandard living conditions — though they said conditions had improved recently.
A UPI photographer working on this story without first having cleared his presence with base public affairs officials was detained for several hours for questioning Tuesday and then released. He was told he would need an Army escort for any further visits to the base. He returned to the base accompanied by an Army escort on Wednesday.
This reporter also was admonished that he had to be accompanied by an Army public affairs escort when on base. The interviews had been conducted without the presence of an escort.
After returning from Iraq, some soldiers spent about eight weeks in Spartan, dilapidated World War II-era barracks with leaking roofs, animal infestations and no air conditioning in the Kentucky heat.
“I arrived here and was placed in the World War II barracks,” one soldier wrote in an internal Fort Knox survey of the conditions. “On the 28th of August we moved out. On 30 Aug. the roof collapsed. Had we not moved, someone would be dead,” that soldier wrote…
“They are treating us like second-class citizens,” said Spc. Brian Smith, who served in Operation Iraqi Freedom until Aug. 16 and said he is having trouble seeing doctors at Fort Knox. The Army evacuated him through Germany for stomach problems, among other things. “My brother wants to get in (the military). I am now discouraging him from doing it,” Smith said.
“I have never been so disrespected in my military career,” said Lt. Jullian Goodrum, who has been in the Army Reserve for 16 years. His health problems do not appear to be severe — injured wrists — but he said the medical situation at Fort Knox is bad. He said he waited a month for therapy. “I have never been so treated like dirt.”

Continue reading

A Husband’s First Hand Account Of Waiting At Home While His Medic Wife Searched for WMD In Iraq

This disorganized operation continues to needlessly rip apart the lives of many a dedicated individual. This story really drives the point home.
The kicker for me was to learn that the troops themselves are expected to buy the supplies for the goose chase!

Mommy’s Back From Iraq

By John E. Bugay Jr. for the Post Gazette.

My wife, Sgt. Bethany Airel, was a Reserve medic in the 203rd Military Intelligence Battalion, the Army’s contribution to the Iraqi Survey Group, the lead entity in the ongoing search for weapons of mass destruction. For what it accomplished, the 203rd probably ought never to have gone. The Pentagon admitted as much in a “secret report” that, thankfully, was reported on by Rowan Scarborough of The Washington Times on Sept. 3: “Weapons of mass destruction elimination and exploitation planning efforts did not occur early enough in the process to allow Centcom to effectively execute the mission. . . . Insufficient U.S. government assets existed to accomplish the mission.”
We didn’t know this in February, when she was activated, when President Bush and his administration were telling us that war with Iraq was imperative to stop Saddam Hussein from distributing his WMDs to terrorist groups that would bring them to America.
Based on reports of a potential “scorched earth” policy by Saddam, Beth spent the next several months training to don her MOPP (Mission Oriented Protective Posture) gear quickly. I never managed to get beyond a debilitating sense of despondency. Nevertheless, I got into a daily schedule of waking the kids for school, packing lunches, seeing them off and then sitting with my 4-year-old daughter while she cried, “I miss Mommy.”
February was a “lockdown” month, but as the start of the war was delayed, the lockdowns gave way to something like weekends off for the soldiers, and so each weekend for several weeks the kids and I packed up the van to travel the 280 miles to Aberdeen, Md., where the 203rd was stationed. Each trip was potentially “the last time we might see Mommy for a while,” and we treated those weekends with all due reverence. We also spent hundreds of dollars in hotel and travel costs over five such weekends.
Recently there have been reports that soldiers have had to purchase equipment and supplies with their own money, and our family has been no different. We “supported the troops” with the purchase of medical supplies she would need to do her job as a medic, and more mundane items she would need in Iraq, such as a foot locker, a laundry tub, mosquito netting and batteries for flashlights, which the Army didn’t provide.
Finally, in mid-April, we did spend our last tearful weekend, and then Beth left for Kuwait and Iraq. The most striking thing about the next few months was the fact that virtually the whole battalion spent all of May and early June in Tallil, near Nasiriyah, “without vehicles, gear, tents, or computers and equipment,” as she wrote to me. The people had been sent by plane, the equipment by boat. “I can’t understand why we’d have everyone move to Iraq and not be able to do any work.”
Beth and I each fell into a deep depression. I went into therapy; she tried to immerse herself in her work. It is often said that soldiers complain about everything and that you shouldn’t make much of it. In a letter dated July 7, she wrote, “the country [Iraq] has a way of making you feel raped and lost.” As a woman, she doesn’t use the word “rape” lightly. The letter was so bad she didn’t send it at the time, because she didn’t want to worry me. I never received another letter from her, even though she had written once a week or so before that…
It is said that the mood of the soldier depends on the mood of the family at home, but the reverse is true as well. The thought of my wife in a country like Iraq was incredibly hard when I thought it was necessary to defend the country from mushroom clouds over New York.
But in the intervening months, I rarely heard from her, though I knew of her depression. It began to look as if the war was more of a bodybuilding flex designed to satisfy the imperial foreign policy cravings of the hawks in the administration, and, well, that gave the whole thing a different sensation.

Continue reading

Five Part Series Of Interviews With Several High Ranking Soldiers On The Front Lines

Here it is — straight from the soldiers. What’s going on “over there.”
I haven’t even read it all yet, but it looks worthy of passing on.
I may write about this in more detail if I have time. But, for now, with everything else going on right now, I just didn’t want to space on making this available to you in a timely fashion.
Scoop has released a five part interview (Part 1 – with an enlisted man that has over 20 years in the service, Part 2 with a sergeant first class, Part 3 with a very recently disillusioned sergeant, Part 4, Part 5 – no link for 5 yet) with soldiers over in Iraq.
Here’s a quote from part one:

US Soldier AWOL Hotline Traffic Up Seventy-five Percent

AWOL State of Mind: Calls From Soldiers Desperate To Leave Iraq Flood Hotline
By Leonard Greene for the NY Post.

Morale among some war-weary GIs in Iraq is so low that a growing number of soldiers – including some now home on R&R – are researching the consequences of going AWOL, according to a leading support group.
The GI Rights Hotline, a national soldiers’ support service, has logged a 75 percent increase in calls in the last 12 weeks, with more than 100 of those calls from soldiers, or people on their behalf, asking about the penalties associated with going AWOL – “absent without leave” – according to volunteers and staffers who man the service.
Many of the calls have come from soldiers who are among those now on the first wave of 15-day authorized leaves that began almost two weeks ago. Some hotline callers have indicated they may not return, staffers said.
“What would happen if I just don’t go back” to Iraq, one soldier asked a worker at a GI support-line center…
So worried is military brass about the prospect of desertion that many soldiers say they have been encouraged to take their leaves in Germany – a stopover – to avoid temptation stateside.
“The military is aware of how low troop morale is,” said Teresa Panepinto, program coordinator of The GI Rights Hotline, a service that dates back to the Korean War. “They’re concerned these people are going to come home and not go back.”…
Panepinto said monthly calls to the hotline have risen from 2,000 to 3,500 in the last three months.
She said many soldiers complained about the length of the Iraq campaign, the rough desert conditions and a U.S. death toll that has risen well above 300, including nearly 180 soldiers killed after President Bush’s May 1 declaration that major combat operations in Iraq had ended.

Continue reading

Our Troops Given Substandard Medical Treatment Upon Returning Home

This was one of the saddest stories I’ve had the displeasure to read in a long time.

Sick, wounded U.S. troops held in squalor

By Mark Benjamin for UPI

Hundreds of sick and wounded U.S. soldiers including many who served in the Iraq war are languishing in hot cement barracks here while they wait — sometimes for months — to see doctors.
The National Guard and Army Reserve soldiers’ living conditions are so substandard, and the medical care so poor, that many of them believe the Army is trying push them out with reduced benefits for their ailments. One document shown to UPI states that no more doctor appointments are available from Oct. 14 through Nov. 11 — Veterans Day.
“I have loved the Army. I have served the Army faithfully and I have done everything the Army has asked me to do,” said Sgt. 1st Class Willie Buckels, a truck master with the 296th Transportation Company. Buckels served in the Army Reserves for 27 years, including Operation Iraqi Freedom and the first Gulf War. “Now my whole idea about the U.S. Army has changed. I am treated like a third-class citizen.”
Since getting back from Iraq in May, Buckels, 52, has been trying to get doctors to find out why he has intense pain in the side of his abdomen since doubling over in pain there.
After waiting since May for a diagnosis, Buckels has accepted 20 percent of his benefits for bad knees and is going home to his family in Mississippi. “They have not found out what my side is doing yet, but they are still trying,” Buckels said.
One month after President Bush greeted soldiers at Fort Stewart — home of the famed Third Infantry Division — as heroes on their return from Iraq, approximately 600 sick or injured members of the Army Reserves and National Guard are warehoused in rows of spare, steamy and dark cement barracks in a sandy field, waiting for doctors to treat their wounds or illnesses.
The Reserve and National Guard soldiers are on what the Army calls “medical hold,” while the Army decides how sick or disabled they are and what benefits — if any — they should get as a result.
Some of the soldiers said they have waited six hours a day for an appointment without seeing a doctor. Others described waiting weeks or months without getting a diagnosis or proper treatment…
Soldiers here estimate that nearly 40 percent of the personnel now in medical hold were deployed to Iraq. Of those who went, many described clusters of strange ailments, like heart and lung problems, among previously healthy troops. They said the Army has tried to refuse them benefits, claiming the injuries and illnesses were due to a “pre-existing condition,” prior to military service.
Most soldiers in medical hold at Fort Stewart stay in rows of rectangular, gray, single-story cinder block barracks without bathrooms or air conditioning. They are dark and sweltering in the southern Georgia heat and humidity. Around 60 soldiers cram in the bunk beds in each barrack.
Soldiers make their way by walking or using crutches through the sandy dirt to a communal bathroom, where they have propped office partitions between otherwise open toilets for privacy. A row of leaky sinks sits on an opposite wall. The latrine smells of urine and is full of bugs, because many windows have no screens. Showering is in a communal, cinder block room. Soldiers say they have to buy their own toilet paper…
That soldier said that after being deployed in March he suffered a sudden onset of neurological symptoms in Baghdad that has gotten steadily worse. He shakes uncontrollably.
He said the Army has told him he has Parkinson’s Disease and it was a pre-existing condition, but he thinks it was something in the anthrax shots the Army gave him.
“They say I have Parkinson’s, but it is developing too rapidly,” he said. “I did not have a problem until I got those shots.”
First Sgt. Gerry Mosley crossed into Iraq from Kuwait on March 19 with the 296th Transportation Company, hauling fuel while under fire from the Iraqis as they traveled north alongside combat vehicles. Mosley said he was healthy before the war; he could run two miles in 17 minutes at 48 years old.
But he developed a series of symptoms: lung problems and shortness of breath; vertigo; migraines; and tinnitus. He also thinks the anthrax vaccine may have hurt him. Mosley also has a torn shoulder from an injury there.
Mosley says he has never been depressed before, but found himself looking at shotguns recently and thought about suicide.
Mosley is paying $300 a month to get better housing than the cinder block barracks. He has a notice from the base that appears to show that no more doctor appointments are available for reservists from Oct. 14 until Nov. 11. He said he has never been treated like this in his 30 years in the Army Reserves…
Another Army Reservist with the 149th Infantry Battalion said he has had real trouble seeing doctors about his crushed foot he suffered in Iraq. “There are not enough doctors. They are overcrowded and they can’t perform the surgeries that have to be done,” that soldier said. “Look at these mattresses. It hurts just to sit on them,” he said, gesturing to the bunks. “There are people here who got back in April but did not get their surgeries until July. It is putting a lot on these families.”

Continue reading

About To Post A Series Of Really Sad Stories About Our Mistreated Troops (In Iraq and Here At Home!)

I’m about to post a bunch of interviews and articles about our mistreated soldiers — both here at home (as Iraq war veterans start to come home) and our troops that are still over in Iraq.
I hope that you guys understand that I’m just trying to raise awareness about how badly are boys and girls are being mistreated by our own government. Some of this stuff is really shocking and painful to read, so don’t read it if you’ve got to go be upbeat somewhere anytime soon, ok?
No seriously. Read it when you can be alone for a minute, because you’re not going to be in a very good mood afterwards. And for a minute, life seems kinda pointless and stuff.
I’m not expressing myself very well right now, most likely, but I did want to preface this next round of articles with a few words:
I’m torn about what to do at this point about Iraq. I realize that “now we’re committed” and all that and that “now we just can’t pull out and leave the Iraqis hanging” and all that, but if these stories from the troops — from our own side are true, I wonder if it wouldn’t be better to just pull out than to let any more of our troops die for nothing. Or rather, than to let more of them die so that the few entities that are profiting from this war can continue to do so.
I just don’t know guys, so I won’t pretend to have any answers. But I did think it was important to bring you this next round of information — for your own edification. You can draw your own conclusions. Maybe you can help me figure it out.
thanks!

Dick Cheney On Meet the Press – Subject: The Congressional Budget Office’s Claims That Our Forces Are Already Overextended

This is from the September 14, 2003 program of
Meet The Press
, hosted by Tim Russert.
(Link goes to a complete very incomplete transcript.)
Cheney On The Congressional Budget Office’s Claims That Our Forces Are Already Overextended (Small – 7 MB)



Soldiers Punished For Candid Comments


Pentagon may punish GIs who spoke out on TV

By Robert Collier for SF Gate.

But going public isn’t always easy, as soldiers of the Army’s Second Brigade, Third Infantry Division found out after “Good Morning America” aired their complaints.
The brigade’s soldiers received word this week from the Pentagon that it was extending their stay, with a vague promise to send them home by September if the security situation allows. They’ve been away from home since September, and this week’s announcement was the third time their mission has been extended.
It was bad news for the division’s 12,000 homesick soldiers, who were at the forefront of the force that overthrew Saddam Hussein’s government and moved into Baghdad in early April.
On Wednesday morning, when the ABC news show reported from Fallujah, where the division is based, the troops gave the reporters an earful. One soldier said he felt like he’d been “kicked in the guts, slapped in the face.” Another demanded that Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld quit.
The retaliation from Washington was swift.
CAREERS OVER FOR SOME
“It was the end of the world,” said one officer Thursday. “It went all the way up to President Bush and back down again on top of us. At least six of us here will lose our careers.”…
“Our morale is not high or even low,” the letter said. “Our morale is nonexistent. We have been told twice that we were going home, and twice we have received a ‘stop’ movement to stay in Iraq.”…
Yet several U.S. officers said privately that troop morale is indeed low. “The problem is not the heat,” said one high-ranking officer. “Soldiers get used to that. The problem is getting orders to go home, so your wife gets all psyched about it, then getting them reversed, and then having the same process two more times.”
In Baghdad, average soldiers from other Army brigades are eager to spill similar complaints.
“I’m not sure people in Washington really know what it’s like here,” said Corp. Todd Burchard as he stood on a street corner, sweating profusely and looking bored. “We’ll keep doing our jobs as best as anyone can, but we shouldn’t have to still be here in the first place.”
Nearby, Pfc. Jason Ring stood next to his Humvee. “We liberated Iraq. Now the people here don’t want us here, and guess what? We don’t want to be here either,” he said. “So why are we still here? Why don’t they bring us home?”

Continue reading

Vietnam Vets Don’t Take Kindly To Shrub’s Tough Remarks – 2 of 2

Political Veteran
By Peter Carlson for The Washington Post.

Last fall, Cleland voted for the resolution authorizing President Bush to attack Iraq, but now he feels he was bamboozled.
“I voted for it because I was told by the secretary of defense and by the CIA that there were weapons of mass destruction there,” he says. “The president said it, Colin Powell said it, they all said it. And now they can’t find them! Our general over there, who has no dog in this fight, he said he sent troops all over the place and they found two trailers and not much of anything else. So we went to war for two trailers?”
The war in Iraq is beginning to look awfully familiar to Max Cleland.
“Now wait a minute,” he says. “Let me run this back: We have a war. A bunch of Americans die. After the war, we try to figure out why we were there. There’s a commitment of 240,000 ground troops with no exit strategy. You know what that’s called? Vietnam! Hey, I’ve been there, done that, got a few holes in my T-shirt.”

Continue reading